The admin (PCM2) is on holiday until November 23rd. Posting on the forum will be restricted during this period - no new topics or user registrations are accepted and replies to existing threads will be limited.
Buying a monitor? Please refer to this post before purchasing.
New user? Register here.
- Posts
MartiniThanks!
Sadly, the Dell is currently out of stock in France, so I’ll have to wait a bit more, unless I find a reasonably priced alternative.
unciaMartini, if the Asus VG34VQL1B is available where you are, I’d suggest it to you. I purchased mine in June of last year, and it’s really nice once calibrated. I’m a graphic designer and photographer, so I might be more particular about such things. I’m sure the out of box settings are fine for most people. It’s also capable of 10 bit processing up to 144Hz, or 8 bit at 165Hz, so goes to a slightly higher refresh rate than the Dell S3422DWG. It has a bit more pronounced curve, 1500R compared to 1800R though, in case that’s a concern for you. Color gamut is the same as the Dell. Maximum brightness is a bit higher. Contrast is the best I’ve seen from a VA. VA glow isn’t bad so long as you’re viewing it straight on from the center. Anything off angle will show it become more pronounced, but that’s typical with these panels. Static interlacing is far less pronounced with this CSOT panel when compared to the Samsung panels I’ve seen previously, which is probably what Dell is using there. Adam might correct me here.
I do, however have a single dead pixel. It seems common with VA panels as I’ve experienced it multiple times with multiple panels at this point. It’s the luck of the draw these days when it comes to monitors. It’s so small and out of my usual field of view that I just live with it. I only notice it on a white background if I go looking for it. Also, the Dell looks to have a bit better build quality, where Asus is a bit cheap in that regard. It’s not terrible, but it’s also not on the level of LG when it comes to their ultrawides. If you can find this model through Amazon, I’d still recommend you give it a try. Best of luck in whatever you decide to do.
PCM2Glad you’re still enjoying the VG34VQL1B, Uncia. Hopefully that dead pixel isn’t in a super-obvious place and is easy enough to ignore.
Just to note that the S3422DWG has very likely entirely transitioned over to using a
CSOT(confirmed as AUO) panel as well now. This will be the case for any model originally using Samsung panels, such as the CU34G2X – because monitor manufacturers can only now use stockpiled Samsung panels (until they run out) or simply switch to a different panel manufacturer. There was a related post I made on this from summer last year when Samsung was full swing into their transition away from LCD technology. And I mentioned it with reference to the UltraWides earlier on this thread. Samsung has basically handed over the reins to CSOT and AUO who use their ‘panel recipes’ – CSOT is even responsible for the panels used in Samsung’s own flagship VA models like the Odyssey Neo G9 and will likely be the manufacturer for the upcoming Odyssey Neo G8‘s panel. 🙂
flyingspatulaHi PCM2, I believe there may be a possibility the Dell S3422DWG is an AUO panel. If I take a look at the service manual, it lists the panel as LBA340QVR10D010X0R which looks very similar to AUO’s recent VA naming scheme M340QVR01.0/M340QVR01.6.
PCM2Bingo! You’re absolutely right flyingspatula, thanks for pointing this out. 🙂
kllr007Tried S3422DWG but it has really bad flickering, even on 70-80FPS gameplay. Can not recommend it to Nvidia owners if they want Gsync Compt. usable.
PCM2Thanks for confirming that, kllr007. What GPU are you using, specifically? It’s a shame the monitor seems to have bad VRR flickering which is an unfortunate plague affecting quite a few VA models.
PCM2Just to note that our budget IPS UltraWide recommendation for gaming has been updated to the HP X34. This uses a newer version of the Acer XV340CK P’s BOE IPS-ADS panel and includes a shifted blue peak for the backlight to potentially improve viewing comfort (‘Eyesafe’ certified). It has a more powerful (brighter) backlight, but it’s still a standard gamut rather than wide gamut model. For those who don’t mind a flat UltraWide and are in a pretty tight budget but want to go the IPS route, I feel this is a good option to consider.
calindevaHello
I’ve recently decided to change my monitor from what I current have (ASUS TUF Gaming VG27WQ1B) to an Ultra wide monitor.
In the past I’ve had a Alienware 25 inch 240hz TN, can’t remember the exact name, it served me good for games but upgrading to a 27” 2560/1440 monitor changed how I work and game.So I want to upgrade again, but this time to an ultra wide screen.
I have in mind and found in my budget this monitors:
– SAMSUNG Odyssey G5 LC34G55TWWRXEN, 34″, WQHD, 165Hz, AMD FreeSync Premium (377$)
– AOC 34″ WQHD HDR10 144Hz U34G3XM/EU (326$)
– Lenovo 34″, UltraWide, 1500R, FrameLess, QHD, FreeSync, 144Hz G34w-10 (341$)If needed I can stretch up my budget for this but only if there is a massive difference:
–AOC 34″, UltraWide QHD, 1ms, 144Hz, FreeSync CU34G2X (426$)
-Gigabyte 34″, UWQHD, DisplayPort, 144Hz, G34WQC (460$)
-Huawei Mateview GT 34” WQHD, 165Hz, 1500R, HDR (442$)I work from home (Game development in Unity) where I need a lot of screen real estate, and I also game (Mostly SP games, some FPS and from time to time Racing simulators). I have 2 auxiliary screens, 1x 24 inch old TN panel and the screen of my laptop 15.6 inch, and I am willing to lose the 24 inch in favor of this ultra wide.
I am mostly looking at the Samsung G5, Aoc U34G3XM/EU and Lenovo, but can’t decide between them, I really like the idea of 1000r on the Samsung, but from what I’ve read 1500r its not bad on Ultra wide, I have 1500r on my screen now but its only a 27”. If the more expensive ones are better, I can stretch up to them.PCM2Hi calindeva,
I’ve merged your thread with this one as it’s a suitable place and some of the models you’ve mentioned plus others are discussed here. Many of the options you’re considering are going to offer you a very similar experience really, the AOC CU34G2X remains a well-balanced and relatively well tuned option. But it’s tough to recommend based on pricing in your region compared to something like the 34″ Odyssey G5 as the experience offered is ultimately rather similar and I feel you’re overpaying for the AOC CU34G2X in comparison.
Having said that, I personally feel 1500R is a perfectly comfortable and easy to adapt to curve on an ultrawide. Whereas 1000R can take more adaptation and for some would feel a bit on the steep side. A 1000R curve isn’t as obvious or potentially obnoxious on an ultrawide model as a 16:9 model, but it’s still more of a ‘feature’ than a 1500R curve which is more likely to feel natural.
calindevaSo from them, would you recommend the G5? The other AOC and the Lenovo are bad options? Or they are really not worth the 20-50$ difference from them to the G5?
PCM2I would say it’s best to stick to a 1500R curve to be honest, based on my personal experiences but also discussions I’ve had with others. You may end up really liking 1000R, but it’s a bit divisive due to how steep it is and I don’t personally feel it offers any real benefits compared to 1500R on an ultrawide. Perhaps a greater feeling of depth when playing a game, but that same feeling can be less welcome on the desktop when you’re working. It’s very subjective and it’s something you’d need to judge for yourself. But based on that you could rule out the Odyssey G5 and likewise the AOC CU34G3S due to their 1000R curve.
The Lenovo G34w-10 isn’t a model I’ve personally gathered feedback on or have experience with, but it’s worth noting that it is a standard gamut monitor rather than wide gamut like the other options you’re considering. That will limit its vibrancy, especially when coupled with the colour consistency issues of VA panels. Although you shouldn’t find it any worse (hopefully better) in that respect compared to your old Alienware AW2518H(F). If you would prefer a more vibrant look, that actually brings the CU34G2X back into the equation based on your pricing. If you don’t need or feel it’s essential to have a curve, I wouldn’t discount the flat IPS alternatives that are mentioned on this thread and are recommended such as the HP X34, either.
PCM2Sorry, I realise now you were looking at the AOC U34G3XM and not the CU34G3S. I don’t have any feedback to share on the U34G3XM as I tend not to closely follow or gather feedback on models that aren’t available in the US. That’s where the vast majority of our supporting audience is based so that’s I prefer focusing my attention towards models available there as well. But if you’re happy to go for a flat screen then I’d again consider the IPS options instead. At a basic level, the pixel responsiveness and colour performance is superior, but that comes at the expense of contrast. So it depends what you’re after really.
I got the impression from reading your posts that you quite liked curved screens, so Samsung Odyssey G5 is probably the one to try if you’re happy for that to be a steep 1000R curve. Otherwise it depends on your view on the possible lack of vibrancy on the Lenovo G34w-10 or paying more for the CU34G2X. 🙂
calindevaThank you so much for the response, I am thinking between the G5 New or the Lenovo G34, I’ve found it used at 250$, used but practically brand new. Its so tough to choose I swear, I think I would really like the 1000r curve for the immersion. I really like the IPS 34 HP, but I really like the curve feature.
calindevaI’ve found some alternatives that are better (I think) and also the price is resonable:
iiyama G-Master GB3466WQSU (432$) I like it because i see that it has ~436 cd/m2 vs the AOC CU34G2X which has ~230 cd/m2
Gigabyte 34″ G34WQC A (422$) Pretty good from what I see on Rtings
AOC 34″ CU34G2X I know that you’ve recommended it but I’ve found it now at 399$, I think it has a low brightness but nice panel overallPCM2What brightness do you usually set your monitors to? Most people (not everyone) will be absolutely fine with setting the monitor somewhere between 100 – 200 cd/m². The G34WQC A is a decent alternative with higher brightness, I agree with that and it’s good to see it is available at an agreeable price for you. 🙂
JonkeyLooking for best 34 and more inches UW Curved game monitor for less or 600 euro
I need more then 100 Hz, very good colors without smearing behind fast-moving objects.PCM2Hi Jonkey,
I’ve merged your thread with this one as it’s a suitable place (regardless of specific usage, there are some suggestions here which fit what you’re looking for). You absolutely need to avoid VA models to avoid “smearing behind fast-moving objects” in the ultrawide space – and IPS alternatives certainly fit the “very good colours” criteria better. With this in mind you’re either going to have to expand your budget so something like the LG 34GN850 fits or consider a flat option such as the HP X34.
JonkeyThank u very much! This forum is so clear beacouse of ur work, good job!
JonkeyHonestly, LG UltraGear 38GN950P-B and LG UltraGear 34GN850P-B was my first choice, but I want to have my monitor’s brightness on very low level all the time so contrast is meaningful factor. I heared that blacks on the screen look grayish, especially in a dark environments.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.